14 min read
5.0
6

Does milk hydrate better than water? What the research shows

Milk was kept in the body better than water in a 13-drink trial. What the beverage hydration index means, its limits, whether coffee dehydrates you, and what to drink in heat, after training and when ill.

A calm glowing lake between mountains under a full moon
An explainer on whether milk hydrates better than water. In a 2016 randomized trial in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (Maughan et al.), 72 healthy, fasted, euhydrated men drank 1 L of one of 13 drinks over 30 minutes and urine was collected for 4 hours. The beverage hydration index (BHI) compares urine after still water with urine after each drink. Oral rehydration solution (BHI about 1.54), full-fat milk (1.50) and skim milk (1.58) were retained better than water; 4-hour urine was about 1,040–1,050 g versus about 1,340 g for water. Sparkling water, sports drink, orange juice, cola, diet cola, tea, iced tea, coffee and lager did not differ from water. Authors link milk's advantage to sodium and potassium and slower gastric emptying. Moderate coffee did not dehydrate: in a crossover study of 50 habitual coffee drinkers, four 200 ml cups a day matched water on total body water and urine volume (Killer 2014). Mayo Clinic counts tea, coffee and milk toward daily fluid and cites about 2.7–3.7 L of total fluid a day. The article covers dehydration, resting heart rate and HRV, heat and training, red flags from the Cleveland Clinic, and how Welltory helps track morning heart rate and HRV without measuring hydration.

Short answer

Yes — in a controlled study, milk kept people hydrated a little longer than plain water. In a randomized trial of 13 drinks, full-fat milk, skim milk and an oral rehydration solution were retained in the body better than still water over the next few hours, so people passed less urine after drinking them (1).

That doesn't make milk better for everyday drinking. The study tested 1 liter drunk in 30 minutes by healthy, fasted men; water is still the simplest, calorie-free way to meet most of your daily fluid needs (1, 3). Milk helps most when you need fluid to stay in — after sweating, in the heat, or when you can't drink often.

And coffee in moderate amounts doesn't seem to dehydrate you. In the same trial coffee was no different from water, and in a separate study four cups of coffee a day hydrated habitual coffee drinkers as well as the same amount of water (1, 2).

If you've been forcing down glasses of water you don't want and still feel drained, you're not doing it wrong. What you drink, when, and what you lose through sweat all change how much of it stays.

Note: this article is for general education and is not medical advice. Confusion, fainting, a seizure or a high fever with signs of dehydration need urgent care: call 911 or your local emergency number. Babies, young children, older adults and people with kidney or heart conditions should follow their doctor's fluid advice. This guide is published by Welltory, which makes one of the apps mentioned. Welltory is a general wellness product and does not diagnose or treat any condition.

Black Friday banner background
Black Friday banner background

Start understanding your body

Learn what affects your energy, stress, sleep, and daily state. Get the app.

What "hydrating" actually means

Every drink is mostly water, so every drink adds fluid. The real question is how much of it your body keeps. Some of what you drink is passed as urine within an hour or two; the rest stays in your blood and tissues.

Your kidneys decide how much to let go. If a drink comes with sodium and potassium, or takes longer to leave the stomach, the kidneys see the water arrive more slowly and in better balance — and hold on to more of it. Plain water on an empty stomach arrives fast and, if you are already well hydrated, a good share of it leaves fast too.

That is why "Is milk hydrating?" is a fair question with a surprising answer.

Black Friday banner background
Black Friday banner background

Discounts for blog readers: up to 36% off

See what affects your energy, stress, sleep, and daily state with Welltory

The study behind the claim: the beverage hydration index

In 2016, researchers from several UK universities published a trial in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition that created the beverage hydration index (BHI) (1).

How it worked, step by step:

  1. 72 healthy, physically active men came in after an overnight fast and in a normal state of hydration.

  2. Each drank 1 liter of a test drink over 30 minutes — still water plus three of the other drinks on separate days.

  3. Researchers collected all urine for the next 4 hours.

  4. They compared the urine after each drink with the urine after water. The BHI is the urine after water divided by the urine after the test drink, corrected for the drink's water content. A BHI above 1 means the drink was kept better than water.

The 13 drinks: still water, sparkling water, an oral rehydration solution (ORS), a sports drink, full-fat milk, skim milk, orange juice, cola, diet cola, hot tea, iced tea, coffee and lager.

What the results showed

  • Oral rehydration solution — Kept better — BHI about 1.54

  • Full-fat milk — Kept better — BHI about 1.50

  • Skim milk — Kept better — BHI about 1.58

  • Orange juice, sports drink, sparkling water — No significant difference

  • Cola, diet cola — No significant difference

  • Hot tea, iced tea, coffee — No significant difference

  • Lager (beer) — No significant difference

Total urine over 4 hours was about 1,040–1,050 g after milk or ORS, compared with about 1,340 g after water (1). Put simply: from a liter of milk, roughly 300 ml more stayed in the body over those hours than from a liter of water.

Why milk is more hydrating than water

The researchers pointed to two main reasons (1):

  • Electrolytes. Milk naturally contains sodium and potassium. The drinks with the most electrolytes tended to have the highest BHI — the oral rehydration solution, which is designed around sodium, scored just as well as milk.

  • Energy and slower emptying. Milk contains protein, fat and lactose (milk sugar). Drinks with more energy leave the stomach more slowly, so water reaches the blood more gradually and the kidneys don't flush it out as quickly.

Interestingly, skim milk did as well as full-fat milk, so the fat isn't essential. And energy alone didn't explain everything: orange juice, cola and lager also contain energy but weren't kept better than water (1).

The limits of the study

This is one well-run trial, and its authors are clear about what it can't tell you (1):

  • Only men took part, so the results may not apply equally to women.

  • Fasted and already hydrated. Nobody was dehydrated at the start, and nobody ate.

  • One large drink. A liter in 30 minutes is not how most people drink through the day.

  • Short follow-up. It measured 4 hours; whole-day effects weren't tested directly.

  • Mixed ingredients. Real drinks contain many things at once, so the trial couldn't say exactly which ingredient made the difference.

So "milk hydrates better than water" is true in a specific, narrow sense. It is not a reason to swap all your water for milk.

Does coffee dehydrate you?

This is one of the most-searched hydration questions — and the evidence is more reassuring than the myth.

In the hydration index trial, coffee with about 212 mg of caffeine per liter produced the same urine output as water. The authors saw no effect of moderate caffeine (roughly 96–212 mg in the drinks tested) on net fluid balance (1).

In a separate study, 50 men who usually drank 3–6 cups of coffee a day drank four 200 ml cups of coffee a day (about 4 mg of caffeine per kg of body weight) for several days, and then the same amount of water. Total body water, blood markers and 24-hour urine volume didn't differ between the two; the authors concluded that moderate coffee offers "similar hydrating qualities to water" in regular coffee drinkers (2).

What this means:

  • Does coffee count as water intake? Mostly, yes. Mayo Clinic says tea, coffee and milk help keep you hydrated and count toward your daily fluid (3).

  • The caveat. Some clinical sources still advise against caffeine and alcohol for "optimal hydration" (4). Very large doses, or caffeine when you're not used to it, may act differently than a habitual morning cup. And coffee affects more than fluid: heart rate, sleep and the stomach. See coffee on an empty stomach and caffeine: wired and tired.

Alcohol is different. Lager didn't differ from water in this trial, but it contained alcohol that may have cancelled out its benefits (1). Stronger drinks and more of them make you lose fluid. Our guide on how long the body takes to recover after drinking covers the next day.

The most hydrating drinks, ranked by situation

There is no single best drink for hydration — it depends on what you need.

SituationGood choiceWhy
Everyday drinkingWater, tea, coffee in moderationCount toward fluid; no extra calories in water (3)
After a sweaty workoutMilk, or water plus a salty snackMilk was kept better than water (1)
Long activity or long sun exposureSports drinkReplaces fluid plus sodium and potassium lost in sweat (4)
Vomiting, diarrhea, feverOral rehydration solution, brothDesigned to replace fluid and electrolytes (3, 4)
Can't drink often (travel, long meetings)Milk or ORS before you goStay in the body longer (1)
Before bedSmall glass of water or milkEnough to be comfortable; a large glass may wake you up to use the toilet

What about other milks?

The trial tested only cow's milk. Chocolate milk adds sugar and some extra energy, and is popular as an after-workout drink. Plant milks such as almond, oat and coconut milk differ a lot in protein, electrolytes and sugar from brand to brand, and they weren't tested, so we can't say whether they are more hydrating than water. Coconut milk is not the same as coconut water. If you can't drink cow's milk, water with a salty snack or an oral rehydration solution is a well-tested alternative.

How much should you drink?

Mayo Clinic notes that some studies suggest the average healthy adult gets enough with about 11.5 to 15.5 cups (2.7 to 3.7 liters) of total fluid a day, including all drinks — and that food provides about 20% of the water you need (3). The same source suggests two simple checks:

  1. Your urine is colorless or light yellow.

  2. You rarely feel thirsty.

You need more when you sweat during exercise, in hot or humid weather, at high altitude, and when you're losing fluid from vomiting, fever or diarrhea (3).

Dehydration, heart rate and HRV

When you're low on fluid, there is less volume in your blood vessels. To keep blood pressure up, your heart beats faster. The Cleveland Clinic lists a high heart rate with low blood pressure among the signs of dehydration in adults (4). Our article can dehydration cause high blood pressure? explains how blood pressure responds.

What you may notice in your own data:

  • A resting heart rate a few beats higher than your usual on a hot day, after a hard workout without enough fluid, or the morning after drinking alcohol.

  • A lower HRV on some of those mornings — worth noting in your own data rather than assuming. Many other things move HRV too — sleep, stress, illness — so look for a pattern, not a single reading. See why HRV fluctuates day to day.

  • A bigger heart rate jump when you stand up, and feeling lightheaded. If this happens a lot, even when you drink well, read about POTS symptoms.

People with POTS are often told to drink more and to choose fluids that stay in — Dysautonomia International lists milk, electrolyte drinks, tea, smoothies and soups alongside water (5).

Heat and training

Heat adds two loads at once: you sweat out water and salt, and your body sends more blood to the skin to cool down. That's why heart rate drifts up on hot days even at the same effort. Our guides to heat intolerance and whether summer heat affects your blood pressure go further.

A simple routine for hot days or long workouts:

  1. Start hydrated. Drink with your meals before you go, rather than gulping a bottle at the door.

  2. Sip during long or sweaty sessions. For longer activity, a sports drink replaces sodium and potassium as well as water (4).

  3. Afterward, choose something that stays in. A glass of milk, or water with a salty snack, fits what the hydration index trial found (1).

  4. Check the next morning. Urine color, thirst, and your resting heart rate compared with your usual.

Common mistakes

  • Chugging lots of water at once. Much of it passes straight through if you're already hydrated.

  • Thinking coffee "cancels out" water. At moderate intake it counts as fluid (2, 3).

  • Using sports drinks as everyday drinks. They make sense for long activity, not at a desk.

  • Swapping all water for milk. Milk brings calories, and many adults don't digest lactose well.

  • Forgetting food. About a fifth of your water comes from food (3).

  • Relying on thirst in older age. Adults 65 and older are at higher risk of dehydration (4).

Living with hydration questions: what people ask next

Is milk good for hydration after a workout?

Yes. In the hydration index trial, milk was kept in the body better than water over the following hours (1). It also brings protein. If you sweat heavily or train for a long time, combine it with water or a sports drink.

Is chocolate milk hydrating?

Chocolate milk is still milk, so it contains water, electrolytes, protein and lactose, plus added sugar. It wasn't tested in the trial, so we can't give it a hydration index, but it's a reasonable after-workout option if you tolerate it.

Is almond milk hydrating?

It counts as fluid, but almond milk wasn't tested and usually contains far less protein than cow's milk. We don't know whether it's more hydrating than water.

Does tea dehydrate you?

In the hydration index trial, hot and iced tea weren't different from water (1). Mayo Clinic counts tea toward your daily fluid (3).

Should kids drink milk for hydration?

Children's fluid needs depend on age and size, and they're at higher risk of dehydration because they may not say they're thirsty (4). For a child who is vomiting or has diarrhea, ask your pediatrician; electrolyte solutions may be recommended.

Before you blame yourself

If you feel flat in the afternoon or wake up with a racing heart, it's easy to think you're simply bad at drinking water. That's not laziness. Before you blame yourself, look at your data. A heart rate a few beats above your usual and a dip in HRV often line up with a visible cause: a hot day, a long run, a late glass of wine, or a morning with only coffee. Pick one lever for one to two weeks — for example, a glass of milk or water with a salty snack after training, or a drink with breakfast before coffee — and see whether your mornings change.

When to see a doctor

See a doctor if you're often thirsty no matter how much you drink, pass large amounts of urine, feel dizzy when you stand most days, or have dark urine and tiredness that don't improve with more fluid.

The Cleveland Clinic advises calling 911, your local emergency number, or going to the emergency room right away for severe dehydration — warning signs include a fever of 103°F (39.4°C) or higher, confusion, fainting and seizures (4). For babies, young children and older adults, act sooner.

How to bring this up with your doctor

What to ask for, by name. "Could we check my electrolytes, kidney function and blood sugar?" If you get dizzy when standing: "Could you check my heart rate and blood pressure lying and standing?"

What to bring. A few days of notes: what you drank and roughly how much, urine color, symptoms, and any resting heart rate readings. List your medicines — some affect fluid balance.

What to say, out loud. "Even when I drink about [amount] a day, I still feel [thirsty / dizzy / tired], especially when [situation]."

If you're told to just drink more. Ask: "What should I drink, how much, and what would make you look for another cause?"

How Welltory helps — and what it cannot do

The limits first. Welltory is a general wellness product, not a medical device. It doesn't measure hydration, electrolytes or blood volume, and it can't tell you how much to drink.

What it can do is show you how your body responds to heat, training and habits over time.

Morning heart rate and HRV. You can take a spot measurement with your phone camera and flash — a short, deliberate reading, not 24/7 tracking (camera measurements). Measure at the same time each morning, before coffee (accurate HRV measurements).

Tag what you change. When Welltory detects a stress or recovery episode and asks "What happened?", you can tap a suggested tag, type, or answer by voice — "hot day", "long run", "milk after training", "only coffee" (My Patterns).

A record for your doctor. From the web app you can export your data as CSV: Dashboard → choose a chart → pick the time range → Export (export guide).

How we made it

We based this article on the randomized trial that created the beverage hydration index, a crossover study of coffee and hydration in habitual coffee drinkers, Mayo Clinic's guidance on daily water intake, the Cleveland Clinic's overview of dehydration, and Dysautonomia International's POTS treatment guidance. Search questions came from what people in the United States most often ask about milk, coffee and hydration. For the product section, we checked every function against the Welltory Help Center on November 9, 2026.

Made with AI tools, then edited and fact-checked by the Welltory team. See our Editorial & AI policy.

Jane Smorodnikova, co-founder of Welltory, built the methodology behind how we read physiological data.

Written by Tatsiana Yashyna.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not medical advice. Confusion, fainting, a seizure or a high fever with signs of dehydration need urgent care: call 911 or your local emergency number. Babies, young children, older adults and people with kidney or heart conditions should follow their doctor's fluid advice. This guide is published by Welltory, which makes one of the apps mentioned. Welltory is a general wellness product: it helps you track and understand your data and does not diagnose or treat any condition. Sources were retrieved on November 6, 2026.

Was this helpful?

Ask AI for a summary of page

ChatGPTGeminiClaudePerplexityGrok

Written by Jane Smorodnikova

The founder and CEO of Welltory. A recognized tech leader with two Master's degrees and experience at MIT, she has scaled Welltory to over 17 million users.

Written by Tatsiana Yashyna

Deputy COO at Welltory. With a background in medicine and years of working with health data, she translates research and real physiological signals — sleep, stress, heart rate, and hormones — into clear, evidence-based explanations that help people understand what their bodies are telling them.

References

  1. Maughan RJ, Watson P, Cordery PAA, et al. A randomized trial to assess the potential of different beverages to affect hydration status: development of a beverage hydration index. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 2016;103(3):717–723. doi:10.3945/ajcn.115.114769. https://dspace.stir.ac.uk/handle/1893/22892
  2. Killer SC, Blannin AK, Jeukendrup AE. No evidence of dehydration with moderate daily coffee intake: a counterbalanced cross-over study in a free-living population. PLOS ONE 2014;9(1):e84154. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0084154
  3. Mayo Clinic — Water: How much should you drink every day? https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/nutrition-and-healthy-eating/in-depth/water/art-20044256
  4. Cleveland Clinic — Dehydration. https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/9013-dehydration
  5. Dysautonomia International — POTS treatment essentials. https://dysautonomiainternational.org/pdf/POTSTreatmentEssentials.pdf
  6. Welltory Help Center — Taking measurements with your smartphone camera. https://help.welltory.com/en/articles/4412277-taking-measurements-with-your-smartphone-camera
  7. Welltory Help Center — How to take accurate heart rate variability measurements. https://help.welltory.com/en/articles/3361520-how-to-take-accurate-heart-rate-variability-measurements
  8. Welltory Help Center — My Patterns (iOS). https://help.welltory.com/en/articles/16012012-my-patterns-ios
  9. Welltory Help Center — How to export data from Welltory. https://help.welltory.com/en/articles/3368391-how-to-export-data-from-welltory

FAQ